Flat Top Griddles, Gas Grills, Tips & Techniques
Griddle vs Grill: What's the Difference?
A griddle cooks food on a solid flat metal surface using direct conduction heat. A grill cooks food over grates using radiant heat from a flame below. The result is fundamentally different: a griddle produces an even crust across the entire food surface with no char flavor; a grill produces grill marks, char, and smoke flavor. Neither is better – they produce different results and suit different foods.
Griddle vs Grill at a Glance
| Factor | Flat top griddle | Gas grill |
|---|---|---|
| Heat type | Direct conduction - surface to food | Radiant heat – flame below grates |
| Cooking surface | Solid flat metal - full contact | Grates – contact points only |
| Smoke/char flavor | None - flavor from browning only | Yes – char and flame flavor |
| Flare-ups | No flare-ups | Yes – fat drips onto flame |
| Best for | Eggs, pancakes, smash burgers, fried rice, fish | Steaks, whole chicken, ribs, vegetables with char |
| Temperature control | Precise - independent zone control | Good – zone control with lid management |
| Cleaning | Scraper + water - 2 minutes | Grate cleaning – more involved |
| Portability | Bulkier - not for travel | More portable options available |
| Price range | $250-$800 for quality options | $200-$1,500+ depending on size |
How Each One Cooks
How a flat top griddle cooks
A flat top griddle transfers heat directly from the metal surface into food – this is conduction cooking. Every part of the food in contact with the surface receives equal heat, which produces:
- An even crust across the entire face of the food – no grill marks, uniform browning
- Better moisture retention – the sealed surface keeps juices inside rather than dripping through grates
- No flare-ups – fat stays on the surface and can be scraped away rather than igniting below
- Precise temperature control – the surface temperature is directly set by the burner output
The Nexgrill Daytona 4-Burner Griddle uses four independent burners under a solid, cold-rolled steel surface, allowing you to maintain different temperature zones across the cooking area at the same time.
How a gas grill cooks
A gas grill heats food using radiant heat – the flame heats the grates, and the grates and surrounding air heat the food. Food rests on raised grates above the flame, which means:
- Grill marks where the food contacts the grate – not a full crust
- Char and smoke flavor from fat dripping onto the flame and vaporizing back up into the food
- Flare-ups when fat hits the flame – causes charring if not managed
- Indirect heat capability with lid closed – allows roasting-style cooking
Gas grills like the Nexgrill 4-Burner Gas Grill offer zone cooking by leaving some burners on and others off, with the lid acting as an oven for indirect heat.
What Each One Does Better
Foods that are better on a flat top griddle
- Eggs – any style, precise temperature control, no sticking
- Pancakes and French toast – even heat, no hot spots, perfect browning
- Smash burgers – full surface contact creates a crust that grates cannot replicate
- Bacon – lies flat, fat renders evenly, no flare-ups
- Fish fillets – no risk of falling through grates, can be moved gently
- Fried rice – needs the flat surface and high heat for proper texture
- Quesadillas and grilled cheese – full surface contact melts cheese while crisping bread
- Delicate vegetables – caramelize without falling through grates
Foods that are better on a gas grill
- Whole chicken pieces – benefit from indirect heat and the option to roast with the lid closed
- Traditional BBQ – ribs, brisket, and pulled pork benefit from char and smoke flavor
- Thick steaks where char flavor is wanted – a flat top sears better, but a grill adds char
- Whole fish – easier to manage on grates with a fish basket
- Foods that benefit from the lid-closed roasting effect – whole vegetables, stuffed peppers
Can You Get Both in One Product?
Yes. The Nexgrill Gourmet Pro range includes a Griddle Max insert – a flat top griddle plate that sits over the grill grates and converts a section of the grill into a flat cooking surface. This lets you use both cooking styles on the same unit.
Combo products are a good option if you want flat top cooking capability without a second piece of equipment. The trade-off is that the griddle area is smaller than a dedicated flat top griddle, and switching between modes requires removing or replacing the insert.
Which Should You Buy?
Choose a flat top griddle if:
- You cook breakfast foods, smash burgers, eggs, or fried rice regularly
- You want precise temperature zone control across a large cooking surface
- You prioritize easy cleaning – a flat top cleans faster than grill grates
- You cook for a family and need maximum cooking surface area
- You want to avoid flare-ups
Choose a gas grill if:
- You want char flavor and smoke on your food
- You cook traditional BBQ – ribs, whole chicken, brisket
- You want the lid-closed roasting capability for indirect heat cooking
- You want more portable options – compact gas grills travel better than most flat tops
Buy both if:
- You cook a wide range of foods and want the best tool for each
- You host regularly – different cooking styles for different occasions
Many outdoor cooks eventually own both – the flat top for everyday cooking and the grill for traditional BBQ occasions.
Related Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a griddle better than a grill?
Neither is better – they produce different results. A griddle is better for eggs, pancakes, smash burgers, fish fillets, and fried rice. A grill is better for foods that need char flavor, smoke, or indirect heat – ribs, whole chicken, traditional BBQ. The right choice depends on what you cook most.
What is the difference between a griddle and a flat top grill?
"Flat top grill" and "griddle" refer to the same cooking concept: a solid, flat metal cooking surface that cooks food through direct conduction rather than over grates. The terms are used interchangeably. Some products are marketed as griddles (the Nexgrill Daytona Griddle) and some as flat top grills, but the cooking method is identical.
Can a griddle replace a grill?
A griddle can replace a grill for most everyday cooking – burgers, chicken, vegetables, and fish all cook well on a flat top. It cannot replace a grill if you want char flavor, smoke, or the indirect-heat roasting capability of a gas grill with a lid. For traditional BBQ, a grill or smoker is the right tool.
Which is easier to clean - a griddle or a grill?
A griddle is easier to clean. Between-cook cleaning on a flat top takes under 2 minutes – scrape, add water, wipe, apply a thin oil coat. Grill grate cleaning takes longer and requires brushing grates, managing drip trays, and periodic deep cleaning of the firebox. This is one of the main practical advantages of a flat top griddle.
What foods are better on a griddle than a grill?
Eggs, pancakes, smash burgers, bacon, fish fillets, fried rice, quesadillas, and grilled cheese all turn out better on a flat top griddle than on a traditional grill. The full surface contact and precise temperature control of a flat top give these foods an even crust and consistent cook that grates cannot match.