Charcoal Grills & Smokers, Tips & Techniques
Pellet Grill Pros and Cons
A pellet grill's biggest advantage is set-and-forget temperature control – load the hopper, set the temperature, and the controller handles the rest. The biggest disadvantage is that it requires electricity and produces milder smoke flavor than a charcoal smoker. For most home cooks, the convenience outweighs the trade-offs.
Pros and Cons at a Glance
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Set-and-forget temperature control | Requires electricity – needs a power outlet |
| Consistent, reliable results every cook | Milder smoke flavor than offset or charcoal |
| Wide temperature range – smoke, grill, roast, bake | Ongoing pellet cost – more expensive per cook than charcoal |
| Wi-Fi monitoring on the Oakford 36A | Mechanical complexity – auger, firepot, fan can fail |
| Fast startup – 10-15 minutes to cooking temperature | Running out of pellets mid-cook stops the cook |
| Easy to clean – less ash than charcoal | Shorter warranty than some competitors at this price |
| Low learning curve – usable on first session | Cannot use during power outages |
The Pros – in Detail
Set-and-forget temperature control
The defining advantage of a pellet grill. A digital controller (SureTemp on the Oakford 36A) reads the cooking chamber temperature and adjusts pellet feed rate automatically to hold the set temperature. Unlike a charcoal or offset smoker, there is no fire to tend, no dampers to adjust, and no charcoal to add mid-cook.
A 12-hour brisket cook on a pellet grill runs while you go about your day – checking the temperature and meat probe via the Nex-Fi app on your phone, getting a notification when the meat hits the target internal temperature.
Consistent, reliable results
Because the temperature stays within ±15°F of the set point, results are highly repeatable. Cook a pork shoulder at 225°F for 10 hours on the Oakford 36A, and you get consistent results every time. Fire management doesn't affect the outcome.
This reliability is particularly valuable for new smoker cooks – the learning curve is about understanding which temperatures and times suit which cuts, not about managing a fire.
Wide temperature range
The Oakford 36A operates from 180°F to 500°F. This means one cooker handles:
- Low-temperature smoking (180-225°F) – brisket, pork shoulder, ribs
- Mid-temperature roasting (275-350°F) – whole chicken, turkey, vegetables
- High-temperature grilling (400-500°F) – steaks, burgers, chicken breasts
- Baking (325-375°F) - bread, pizza, desserts
A charcoal grill or offset smoker does not offer this range in a single unit.
Wi-Fi monitoring
The Oakford 36A includes Nex-Fi Wi-Fi connectivity as standard – unusual at this price point. Connect the grill to the Nexgrill app to monitor cooking temperature, adjust the set temperature, and read meat probe data from your phone, wherever you are.
For long cooks, this is genuinely useful – no need to be within line of sight of the grill to know what's happening.
Fast startup
The Oakford 36A reaches 225°F in approximately 10-15 minutes from a cold start. An offset smoker takes 40-50 minutes to reach a stable cooking temperature. For mid-week cooks with limited time, the pellet grill's quick startup is a meaningful practical advantage.
Easy cleaning
A pellet grill produces significantly less ash than a charcoal grill or offset smoker. After a cook, the firepot typically has only a small amount of ash, and the cooking chamber has minimal residue. The Oakford 36A has a removable ash cleanout below the firepot and a front-facing grease tray – both accessible without removing the cooking grates.
Low learning curve
Most people produce good results on a pellet grill on their first cook. No fire-management skill is required – the main learning is understanding temperatures and cook times for different proteins, which is the same knowledge needed for any cooking method.
The Cons – in Detail
Requires electricity
A pellet grill needs a power outlet to run the auger, fan, igniter, and controller. This limits where you can use it – mains power or a generator is required. For most backyard setups, this is not a problem. For camping, remote cooking, or power outages, a pellet grill isn't usable.
An offset smoker or charcoal grill is completely self-contained – fuel and a lighter are all that's needed.
Milder smoke flavor
A pellet grill produces less intense smoke than an offset smoker burning charcoal and wood chunks. The smoke is real and adds genuine flavor, but it lacks the depth and complexity associated with competition BBQ and traditional smokehouse cooking.
For most home cooks, pellet grill smoke flavor is excellent. For experienced BBQ enthusiasts who have cooked on offset smokers, the difference is noticeable.
You can increase smoke intensity by cooking at lower temperatures, using stronger pellets (hickory, oak, mesquite), or adding a smoke tube to the cooking chamber, but it will not fully replicate an offset smoker.
Pellet cost
Wood pellets cost more per pound than charcoal. A long cook at 225°F uses approximately 1-2 lbs of pellets per hour – about $1.50-3.00 per hour depending on pellet brand. A comparable charcoal cook costs less in fuel.
For most home cooks, the per-cook cost difference is modest and acceptable given the convenience. For very frequent use, you should factor in the ongoing cost.
Mechanical complexity
A pellet grill has more components than a gas or charcoal grill: auger, firepot, fan, igniter, temperature probe, and controller. More components mean more potential failure points.
In practice, well-maintained pellet grills are reliable. The most common issues are auger jams (usually from wet pellets), firepot ash buildup, and igniter wear after several years of use. Regular cleaning prevents most problems.
Running out of pellets stops the cook
If the hopper empties mid-cook, the auger stops feeding pellets, the fire dies, and the cook ends – potentially hours before the meat is done. The Oakford 36A's 20 lb hopper holds enough pellets for 8-12 hours at 225°F, which covers most cooks.
For very long cooks (16-18 hour briskets), check the pellet level halfway through and top up before it runs low. The hopper window on the Oakford 36A lets you check the level without opening the hopper.
Cannot use during power outages
A pellet grill is non-functional without electricity. If you live in an area with frequent power outages, or want a cooker that works off-grid, a charcoal grill, offset smoker, or gas grill is a better choice.
Who Is a Pellet Grill Right For?
A pellet grill is the right choice for:
- Anyone who wants great smoked food without learning to manage a fire
- Cooks who want to run long cooks and monitor remotely
- People who cook a wide range of foods and want one versatile outdoor cooker
- Anyone new to smoking who wants reliable results from the first cook
A pellet grill is probably not the right choice for:
- Anyone who prioritizes maximum smoke intensity – an offset smoker produces better results for that specific goal
- Off-grid or camping cooking where electricity isn't available
- Buyers looking for the lowest possible fuel cost per cook
Related Guides
- What Is a Pellet Grill? Everything You Need to Know
- Pellet Grill vs Offset Smoker: Which Should You Buy?
- Best Pellet Grill Under $500
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the disadvantages of a pellet grill?
The main disadvantages are: requires a power outlet (cannot be used off-grid or during power outages), produces milder smoke flavor than an offset smoker or charcoal grill, has higher fuel cost per cook than charcoal, and has more mechanical components than simpler cookers. Running out of pellets mid-cook also ends the cook – a 20 lb hopper like the Oakford 36A reduces this risk significantly.
Are pellet grills worth the money?
Yes, for most home cooks. The combination of set-and-forget temperature control, consistent results, wide temperature range, and easy cleaning makes a pellet grill significantly more versatile and convenient than a dedicated smoker or charcoal grill. The Oakford 36A at ~$349 delivers strong value with Wi-Fi monitoring included at a price point where competitors typically charge $100-200 more for the same feature.
Do pellet grills give good smoke flavor?
Yes – pellet grills produce genuine smoke flavor from smoldering wood pellets. The smoke is clean and consistent. It is milder than the smoke produced by an offset smoker burning charcoal and wood chunks, which produces more complex smoke compounds through less controlled combustion. For most home cooks, the pellet grill smoke flavor is excellent; for those who want competition-level smoke intensity, an offset smoker produces better results.
Can a pellet grill replace a gas grill?
Yes, for most uses. The Oakford 36A reaches 500°F and can sear steaks, grill burgers, and cook chicken at high heat. It also smokes, roasts, and bakes – making it more versatile than a gas grill. The main limitation is startup time (10-15 minutes vs. immediate on a gas grill) and the ongoing cost of pellets vs. propane. For everyday cooking, a pellet grill can fully replace a gas grill.
How long do pellet grills last?
With regular cleaning and maintenance, a pellet grill should last 5-10 years of regular home use. The cooking chamber and frame are the most durable components. The auger, igniter, and temperature probe are the parts most likely to need replacement over time – all are serviceable on the Oakford 36A. Keeping the firepot clean of ash and using quality pellets (not wet or dusty pellets) significantly extends lifespan.